800.342.2521 / 419.849.2521
Mon - Thu, 8:00 - 4:00 / Fri, 8:00 - 3:30
1859 Mutual Landlord/Dwelling Insurance
1859 Mutual Landlord/Dwelling Insurance

Ohio Landlord & Rental Property Insurance, Built for Your Rentals.

Rental property is an investment, and it carries risks a standard homeowners policy won't cover. 1859 Mutual's Landlord/Dwelling Insurance protects non-owner-occupied homes and dwellings across Ohio, placed through your local independent agent. Because we're a mutual, we answer to our policyholders, not to shareholders.

landlord/dwelling coverage

What Does Ohio Landlord Insurance Cover?
1859 Mutual's Landlord/Dwelling Insurance is built for Ohio rental and investment properties, placed through your local independent agent. Coverage typically includes:

Dwelling Coverage

Protects the physical structure of your rental property against damage from perils such as fire, storm, or vandalism.†

Premises Liability

Covers you if a tenant or visitor is injured on your property, including legal defense costs and any settlements or judgments.†

Loss of Rental Income

Reimburses you for lost rental income if your property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered loss.†

Optional Coverages

Additional options include coverage for outbuildings, equipment, and landlord furnishings, plus Equipment Breakdown, Underground Utility Line, and Water Back-Up coverage.†
†Policy Terms and Conditions apply

Landlord Insurance vs. Homeowners Insurance

A homeowners policy is written for the home you live in. Once you rent a home to someone else, the risks change. A tenant lives there, visitors come and go, and your rental income depends on the home staying livable.

Landlord/Dwelling Insurance is built for those risks. It protects the structure, covers your premises liability if a tenant or visitor is injured, and can reimburse lost rent while the home is uninhabitable after a covered loss.†

1859 Mutual writes landlord and dwelling coverage for one- to four-family dwellings, rented long-term, seasonally, or short-term.

Your policy protects your building and your liability as the owner. Your tenant's furniture, clothing, and other belongings are not part of it; tenants cover those with their own renters insurance. If you rent the home furnished, your agent can add coverage for landlord furnishings.†

An Ohio two-family rental home covered by 1859 Mutual landlord and dwelling insurance

What we offer

Why Ohio Landlords Choose 1859 Mutual
We've protected Ohio property owners for over 160 years. As a mutual, our policyholders come first, not shareholders. We're Demotech "A, Exceptional" rated, and we work only through local independent agents who know the rental market in your community.

Standalone Policy

Unlike many insurers, 1859 Mutual allows you to insure your rental property without requiring personal property coverage, offering unmatched flexibility.

A Local Agent Who Knows Your Market

Your policy is placed and serviced by a local independent agent who knows the rental market in your community.

Competitive Pricing

We offer robust coverage at competitive rates, helping protect your investment without breaking the bank.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does landlord and dwelling insurance cover in Ohio?

Landlord and dwelling insurance in Ohio typically covers the rental property's structure against fire, storm, and vandalism, premises liability if a tenant or visitor is injured, and loss of rental income while the property is uninhabitable after a covered loss, with optional coverage for outbuildings, equipment, and landlord furnishings, under one policy. 1859 Mutual writes landlord and dwelling coverage for Ohio rental and non-owner-occupied properties through appointed independent agents.

What is the difference between landlord insurance and homeowners insurance?

A homeowners policy is written for the home you live in. Landlord insurance is written for a home you rent to someone else: it protects the structure, covers your premises liability as the owner, and can reimburse lost rent after a covered loss. If you rent out an Ohio home you do not live in, a local independent agent can tell you which policy fits.

Do I need landlord insurance if I rent out my home in Ohio?

If you rent a home to tenants and do not live there, a standard homeowners policy may not cover the risks that come with renting it. Landlord and dwelling insurance is built for those risks. If the property has a mortgage, your lender may also require coverage. A local independent agent can review your situation and place the right policy.

Does landlord insurance cover my tenant's belongings?

No. Landlord insurance protects your building and your liability as the owner. Your tenant's personal belongings are not covered by your policy; tenants protect those with their own renters insurance. If you rent the property furnished, your agent can add coverage for the furnishings you own.

Can I insure an Ohio property I rent out without covering my own belongings?

Yes, 1859 Mutual writes landlord and dwelling coverage as a standalone policy, so you can insure an Ohio rental or non-owner-occupied property without buying personal property coverage you do not need. A local independent agent places the coverage and can add landlord furnishings if you rent the property furnished.

Does 1859 Mutual insure short-term or seasonal rentals in Ohio?

Yes. 1859 Mutual writes landlord and dwelling coverage for one- to four-family dwellings in Ohio, whether you rent them long-term, seasonally, or short-term. A local independent agent places the coverage.

How much does landlord insurance cost in Ohio?

The cost depends on the property, where it is, its risk factors, and the coverage you choose. 1859 Mutual offers landlord and dwelling coverage at competitive rates, and your local independent agent prices the policy for your property. Find an agent near you to get a price for your rental.

How do I get landlord and dwelling insurance from 1859 Mutual in Ohio?

You get 1859 Mutual landlord and dwelling coverage through a local independent agent, who places and services the policy. 1859 Mutual writes coverage only through appointed independent agents across Ohio, so find a local agent near you to get started.

Find a Local 1859 Mutual Agent

Ohio landlord and dwelling insurance from 1859 Mutual is placed through local independent agents. Find an agent near you to protect your rental property.