800.342.2521 / 419.849.2521
Mon - Thu, 8:00 - 4:00 / Fri, 8:00 - 3:30
Policyholder Login
Make a Payment
Agent Login
Become an Agent
Home
Agent Locator
Customer Service
Make a Payment
Submit a Claim
Make a Payment
Submit a Claim
Make a Payment
Select your provider below to securely manage your insurance payments.
Make a Payment
1859 Mutual Policyholders
Access the 1859 Mutual payment portal to securely manage your policy payments.
1859 Mutual Payment Portal
Make a Payment
Pike Mutual Policyholders
Access the Pike Mutual payment portal to securely manage your policy payments.
Pike Mutual Payment Portal
© 2024 1859 Mutual
Privacy Policy
Home
Agent Locator
Customer Service
Make a Payment
Submit a Claim