Enter a ZIP code, city, or address — or use your current location — to see the five closest 1859 Mutual agents.
Enter a location above to see the nearest agents, or browse all 76 agents by region below.
76 independent 1859 Mutual agents serving Ohio homeowners across all five regions of the state.
Serving the Toledo area, Findlay, Tiffin, Defiance and surrounding communities.
Serving the Akron, Canton, Mansfield, and Youngstown areas.
Serving the Columbus area, Delaware, Marion, and Mount Gilead.
Serving Chillicothe, Lancaster, Portsmouth, and the Tuscarawas Valley.
Serving the Dayton area and surrounding communities.