Find a Local Ohio Insurance Agent
Every 1859 Mutual policy is written by an independent agent who lives and works in the Ohio community they serve. Find the one nearest you below.
Find an agent near you
Enter a ZIP code, city, or address — or use your current location — to see the five closest 1859 Mutual agents.
Map will appear here once you search.
Enter a location above to see the nearest agents, or browse all 78 agents by region below.
Browse all agents by region
78 independent 1859 Mutual agents serving Ohio homeowners across all five regions of the state.
Northwest Ohio
Serving the Toledo area, Findlay, Tiffin, Defiance and surrounding communities.
-
Ace Insurance232 Jackson St Unit 109 Sandusky, OH 44870 419-502-9150
-
ARK Insurance Services1039 N. Main St Findlay, OH 45840 419-425-4200
-
Brown & Brown of Ohio - Perrysburg3603 Meadows Drive Perrysburg, OH 43551 419-874-1974
-
Clouse Insurance Agency - Luckey230 N Main Luckey, OH 43443 419-654-3067
-
Clouse Insurance Agency - Tiffin5290 N County Rd 43 Tiffin, OH 44883 419-639-2085
-
Cole-Humphrey Insurance Agency115 N Main St Ada, OH 45810 419-634-8010
-
Darla Baker Insurance Agency - Fremont (formerly Schetzer Insurance)420 Croghan Street Fremont, OH 43420 419-332-5101
-
Darla Baker Insurance Agency LLC531 S Front St Pemberville, OH 43450 419-287-3231
-
Denker Insurance Agency7460 Airport Highway Holland, OH 43528 419-865-5095
-
Financial Design Agency Inc - Findlay1995 Tiffin Avenue, Ste 201 Findlay, OH 45840 419-937-0730
-
Financial Design Agency Inc - Fostoria893 N Countyline Street Fostoria, OH 44830 419-937-0730
-
Financial Design Agency Inc - New Riegel15 W. Tiffin Street New Riegel, OH 44853 419-595-2652
-
Financial Design Agency Inc - Tiffin477 W Perry Street Tiffin, OH 44853 419-937-0730
-
Harrison Insurance Agency126 W Auglaize St Wapakoneta, OH 45895 419-738-4444
-
Hasselbach & Paul Agency107 W. Main Street Bellevue, OH 44811 419-483-2551
-
Kathrens Insurance Agency605 N Main St Bowling Green, OH 43402 419-354-3517
-
Merkle Insurance Agency105 Fisher Ave. Van Wert, OH 45891 419-238-1976
-
Nelson Insurance Agency405 N Main Street Kenton, OH 43326 419-673-8256
-
Newland Heydinger Insurance Agency111 E Columbus Street Kenton, OH 43326 419-674-4116
-
Roehrs-McMillen Insurance Inc414 Clinton Street Defiance, OH 43512 419-784-3979
-
Rose and Kissner Insurance Agency619 5th St Defiance, OH 43512 419-784-9479
-
Safe Harbor Insurance Agency2451 Sawmill Parkway Huron, OH 44839 419-616-5207
-
Stapleton Insurance Group122 North Main Street, PO Box 147 Swanton, OH 43558 419-720-6446
-
Stapleton Insurance Group - Sylvania7250 Crossleigh Ct Toledo, OH 43617 419-720-6446
Northeast Ohio
Serving the Akron, Canton, Mansfield, and Youngstown areas.
-
Action Insurance LLC619 Claremont Ave Ashland, OH 44805 419-289-3240
-
Brown & Brown RS Insurance Services7600 Market St Boardman, OH 44512 330-726-8177
-
Carbone Insurance Services Inc2174 Locust Street South Canal Fulton, OH 44614 330-854-9300
-
CL Agency736 Youngstown Warren Rd Niles, OH 44446 330-652-9191
-
Compass Insurance & Financial Group LLC1060 Claremont Ave Ste 7 Ashland, OH 44805 419-207-1111
-
Cook Insurance Group504 E Main St Ravenna, OH 44266 330-296-3628
-
Dejanovic Insurance LLC5143 Mahoning Ave NW Warren, OH 44483 330-847-7660
-
Distefano Insurance Services Inc2036 Locust Street Canal Fulton, OH 44614 330-854-6637
-
Family Insurance Agency4125 Martindale Rd NE Ste 100 Canton, OH 44705 330-492-2300
-
Gearhart Insurance & Financial102 Main St Ste 205 Wadsworth, OH 44281 330-607-6525
-
Hamilton Insurance Group Inc1669 Lexington Ave Ste B Mansfield, OH 44907 419-526-4700
-
Hawkins Insurance Agency11360 State Route 9 Kensington, OH 44427 330-223-2114
-
Holloway Insurance Agency7985 Lisbon-Salem Rd Lisbon, OH 44432 330-424-9533
-
Holloway Insurance Inc105 S Main St, PO Box 28 Columbiana, OH 44408 330-482-3385
-
Jenkins Insurance Agency885 Southeast Ave Tallmadge, OH 44278 330-633-5511
-
Kim Davis Insurance Agency LLC6091 Alliance Rd NW Ste A Malvern, OH 44644 330-866-3344
-
McFadden Insurance Agency / Wichert Insurance Inc140 S Lisbon St Carrollton, OH 44615 330-627-2525
-
Mega-Minor Insurance Agency - East Liverpool15858 Saint Clair Ave. East Liverpool, OH 43920 330-385-1370
-
Minor Insurance Agency - East Liverpool15700 St. Rt. 170, Suite A East Liverpool, OH 43920 330-385-1370
-
Minor Insurance Agency - Minerva956 E Lincoln Way Minerva, OH 44657 330-868-6913
-
Minor Insurance Agency - Toronto1007 Franklin St., Suite B Toronto, OH 43964 740-537-1282
-
Quest Financial & Insurance Services10574 Ravenna Rd 3rd Floor Twinsburg, OH 44087 855-857-9500
-
SeibertKeck Insurance Partners312 N Cleveland-Massillon Rd Akron, OH 44333 330-753-8700
-
Stark Insurance Agency Inc4125 Martindale NE Ste 300 Canton, OH 44705 330-492-2300
-
Summers Insurance Group1436 S Cleveland-Massillon Rd Copley, OH 44321 330-665-3333
-
Thomas J Andrewsc/o Kemp Insurance Agency, 2146 E High Ave New Philadelphia, OH 44663 330-339-4211
-
United Group Ins Agency Inc2036 Locust Street Canal Fulton, OH 44614 330-658-2111
-
United Independent Agency Alliance2036 Locust Street Canal Fulton, OH 44614 330-854-4504
-
United States Insurance Group / TWFG Insurance Services4526 Stow Rd, Ste B2 Stow, OH 44224 330-688-0981
-
Wilde Corp125 N Main St Rittman, OH 44270 330-927-6025
Central Ohio
Serving the Columbus area, Delaware, Marion, and Mount Gilead.
-
Bolton Insurance Agency5 E Winter St #300 Delaware, OH 43015 614-551-6469
-
Central Ohio Insurance Services, Inc.1205 Hill Road North Pickerington, OH 43147 614-861-3100
-
Eagle Insurance Agency Inc206 1/2 North Columbus St, PO Box 325 Sunbury, OH 43074 740-965-3056
-
eGoodwin Insurance Agency - Marion399 E Church St Marion, OH 43302 740-387-8335
-
eGoodwin Insurance Agency - Powell74 E Olentangy St Powell, OH 43065 740-387-8335
-
Matthew Truttschuh Insurance Agency14 W Main St Lexington, OH 44904 419-775-5758
-
Mid-Ohio Insurance Solutions - Cardington114 W Main St Cardington, OH 43315 419-718-4033
-
Mid-Ohio Insurance Solutions - Galion102 E Church St Galion, OH 44833 419-718-0445
-
MVP Insurance Agency Inc73 S Main St Johnstown, OH 43031-1262 740-966-3180
-
Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency55 W Main St Shelby, OH 44875 419-342-4131
-
Shinaberry Insurance Agency Inc11 West High Street Mount Gilead, OH 43338-1212 419-947-9336
-
Sloan Insurance Center - Bellefontaine1413 S Main St Bellefontaine, OH 43311 937-592-4856
-
Smucker Insurance154 N Chillicothe St Plain City, OH 43064 614-873-3423
-
The Keenan Agency6805 Avery-Muirfield Dr # 200 Dublin, OH 43016 614-764-7000
-
Titan Insurance Services Ltd.752 N High St Worthington, OH 43085 614-398-1494
Southeast Ohio
Serving Chillicothe, Lancaster, Portsmouth, and the Tuscarawas Valley.
-
Conner Insurance Agency1569 E Main St Lancaster, OH 43130 740-654-2848
-
Mission Insurance Agency20 S Shawnee Ave South Zanesville, OH 43701 614-368-9333
-
Rosemount City / Glockner Insurance Agency4746 Scioto Trail Portsmouth, OH 45662 740-354-6216
-
Stockton-Hill Insurance10212 OH-159 Kingston, OH 45644 740-642-3333
-
Thompson Insurance - New Lexington102 S Main St New Lexington, OH 43764 740-342-1986
-
Thompson Insurance - Thornville14888 State Route 13 N Thornville, OH 43076 740-246-6100
Southwest Ohio
Serving the Dayton area and surrounding communities.
-
Eilerman Insurance - Fort Loramie700 E Park St, Ste B Fort Loramie, OH 45845 937-295-2122
-
Eilerman Insurance - Sidney127 S Ohio Ave Sidney, OH 45365 937-492-1647
-
Royal Crest Agency29 W Main St Tipp City, OH 45371 937-667-9359