Become an Agent

1859 Mutual has built a proud legacy of serving communities across Ohio as a locally focused, Ohio-only insurance carrier since its founding in 1859. Today, we partner with a strong and ever-growing network of independent agencies throughout the state.

As an appointed 1859 Mutual agent, you gain a dependable market and a partner that answers the phone. Our agents enjoy:

• Competitive homeowners, landlord/dwelling, and farmowners products
• Reliable admitted paper for hard-to-market standalone homeowners risks
• Responsive, personalized underwriting support from a local team
• A performance-driven contingency program that rewards long-term growth
• Fast, fair claims handling that protects your client relationships
• The backing of a financially strong, Demotech "A, Exceptional" rated mutual

Beyond the products, you gain a real relationship. As a policyholder-owned mutual, we build partnerships that last, with people who know Ohio and stay with you and your clients over the long term.

Complete the form below to start your journey toward becoming an integral part of our enduring Ohio-based community.