800.342.2521 / 419.849.2521
Mon - Thu, 8:00 - 4:00 / Fri, 8:00 - 3:30
  • Welcome to 1859 Mutual

    Bridging Legacy and Tomorrow.

    More than just insurance, 1859 Mutual symbolizes enduring trust and resilience spanning centuries. Prepare for a new era of stability.

a new chapter begins

A New Identity, Unwavering Commitment.

We are excited to announce a significant milestone in our journey: the evolution to 1859 Mutual. This change, marking the union of Woodville Mutual and Pike Mutual, symbolizes our commitment to growth and excellence.

What This Means for You:

  • Steadfast Stability: Retaining our exceptional financial rating, we promise continued trust and reliability.
  • Enriched Offerings: Merging strengths to enhance our service spectrum, tailored for your diverse needs.
  • Seamless Experience: Transitioning smoothly, your policies and coverage remain consistent under 1859 Mutual.

Your Trusted Partner in Insurance, Now and Tomorrow.

We look forward to continuing to serve you with the same dedication and excellence, now and into the future. Together, let's embark on this exciting journey.
Locate an Agent

What we offer

Pioneering Protection
for Every Generation
Discover how our enduring commitment to excellence, community, and stability shapes every solution we offer.

Our Legacy

From our origins in 1859, we've evolved from Woodville Mutual into a leading property insurance provider, committed to protecting Ohio's homes and farms with innovative and comprehensive policies.

Our Services

Specializing in Homeowners and Farmowners insurance, we offer tailored solutions to meet the changing needs of our community, ensuring peace of mind and security for our policyholders.

Financial Strength & Stability

With over 160 years of experience, we've established a legacy of financial strength, ensuring the protection and prosperity of our policyholders for generations to come.

Community Focus

Rooted in Ohio, we are proud of our strong community ties and the personal relationships we build with each policyholder, reflecting our commitment to mutual trust and support.

Tailored Insurance for Home, Farm, and Property

Discover the strength and reliability of 1859 Mutual's insurance products, designed with a deep understanding of your needs. From safeguarding your home and farm to protecting your rental properties, our coverage combines tradition with innovation for your peace of mind.

Homeowners Insurance

1859 Mutual provides essential homeowners insurance to safeguard your investment, offering value and flexibility. Our policies are designed to cover a broad spectrum of needs, ensuring peace of mind against unforeseen losses. With some of the widest standard coverages available, our Homeowners Policy can be customized to fit your specific requirements, combining affordability with comprehensive protection.

Farmowners Insurance

1859 Mutual specializes in insuring Ohio's diverse farming interests, serving everything from commercial farms to hobby estates. As a leading provider with extensive experience, we offer tailored Farmowners insurance policies for owner-occupied farms. Our coverage is designed to meet the unique demands of the agricultural sector, ensuring that your farming operations are fully protected.

Landlord/Dwelling Insurance

Landlord / Dwelling Insurance offers tailored coverage for non-owner occupied properties, ensuring rental dwellings and farm lands are protected without the need to insure any personal property with us. This policy stands alone, providing flexibility uncommon with other insurers.