800.342.2521 / 419.849.2521
Mon - Thu, 8:00 - 4:00 / Fri, 8:00 - 3:30

Locate an Agent

Explore a network dedicated to safeguarding Ohio's communities. These are 1859 Mutual's independent agents; each committed to delivering personalized, top-tier insurance solutions. With a focus on local needs and comprehensive coverage, our agents ensure you're protected today and tomorrow.
Agency Name
Address
Phone Number

ARK Insurance Services
1039 N. Main St, Findlay, OH 45840
419-425-4200

Action Insurance LLC
619 Claremont Ave, Ashland OH 44805
419-289-3240

Advanced Insurance Designs Inc
312 N Cleveland-Massillon Rd, Akron OH 44333
330-753-8700

Alleman Insurance Agency LLC
48603 State Route 536, Sardis, OH 43946
740-483-2281

Carbone Insurance Services Inc
2174 Locust Street South, Canal Fulton OH 44614
330-854-9300

Clouse Insurance Agency - Luckey
230 N Main, Luckey, Ohio 43443
419-654-3067

Clouse Insurance Agency - Tiffin
5290 N County Rd 43 Tiffin, Ohio 44883
419-639-2085

Cole-Humphrey Insurance Agency
115 N Main St. Ada, OH 45810
419-634-8010

Compass Insurance & Financial Group LLC
1060 Claremont Ave Ste 7, Ashland OH 44805
419-207-1111

Darla Baker Insurance Agency LLC
PO Box G, Pemberville, OH 43450-0434
419-287-3231

Dejanovic Insurance LLC
5143 Mahoning Ave NW, Warren OH 44483
330-847-7660

Denker Insurance Agency
7460 Airport Highway Holland, OH 43528
419-865-5095

Distefano Insurance Services Inc
2036 Locust St, PO Box 457, Canal Fulton OH 44614-0457
330-854-6637

Eagle Insurance Agency Inc
206 1/2 North Columbus St, PO Box 325, Sunbury OH 43074
740-965-3056
eGoodwin Insurance Agency - Marion
399 E Church St, Marion, OH 43302
740-387-8335

eGoodwin Insurance Agency - Powell
74 E Olentangy St, Powell, OH 43065
740-387-8335

Family Insurance Agency
4125 Martindale Rd NE Ste 100, Canton OH 44705
330-492-2300

Financial Design Agency Inc - Findlay
1995 Tiffin Avenue, Ste 201 Findlay, OH 45840
419-937-0730

Financial Design Agency Inc - Fostoria
893 N Countyline Street, Fostoria, OH 44830
419-937-0730

Financial Design Agency Inc - New Riegel
15 W. Tiffin Street, New Riegel, OH 44853
419-595-2652

Financial Design Agency Inc - Tiffin
477 W Perry Street, Tiffin, OH 44853
419-937-0730

First American Financial Insurance Agency Inc
73 W Main St, Chillicothe OH 45601
740-851-4112

First Insurance Group - Bowling Green
414 E Wooster St, Bowling Green, OH 43402
419-353-8611

First Insurance Group - Defiance
511 W Fifth St, Defiance, OH 43512
419-784-5431

First Insurance Group - Sylvania
5520 Monroe St. Ste. A, Sylvania, OH 43560
419-472-6075

Gearhart Insurance & Financial
102 Main St Ste 205, Wadsworth OH 44281
330-607-6525

Hamilton Insurance Group Inc
1669 Lexington Ave Ste B, Mansfield OH 44907
419-526-4700

Harrison Insurance Agency
126 W Auglaize St. Wapakoneta, OH 45895
419-738-4444

Hasselbach & Paul Agency
PO Box 327 Bellevue OH, 44811
419-483-2551

Hawkins Insurance Agency
11360 State Route 9, PO Box 179, Kensington OH 44427-0179
330-223-2114

Holloway Insurance Inc
105 S Main St, PO Box 28 Columbiana, OH 44408
330-482-3385

James & Sons
4444 Market St, Boardman, OH 44512
330-788-5051

Jenkins Insurance Agency
885 Southeast Ave, Tallmadge OH 44278
330-633-5511

Kathrens Insurance Agency
605 N Main St, Bowling Green, OH 43402
419-354-3517

Kim Davis Insurance Agency LLC
6091 Alliance Rd NW Ste A, Malvern OH 44644
330-866-3344

MVP Insurance Agency Inc
73 S Main St, Johnstown OH 43031-1262
740-966-3180

Matthew Truttschuh Insurance Agency
1230 Lexington Ave Ste 100, Mansfield OH 44907
419-775-5758

McCoy Insurance Agency Inc
5062 Friendsville Rd, Wooster OH 44691
330-345-7220

McFadden Insurance Agency
PO Box 356 (140 S Lisbon St), Carrollton OH 44615
330-627-2525

Mega-Minor Insurance Agency - East Liverpool
15858 Saint Clair Ave. East Liverpool, OH 43920
330-385-1370

Merkle Insurance Agency
105 Fisher Ave. Van Wert, OH 45891
419-238-1976

Mid-Ohio Insurance Solutions
114 W Main St, Cardington OH 43315
419-718-4033

Mid-Ohio Insurance Solutions
102 E Church St, Galion OH 44833
419-718-0445

Mills-Holloway Insurance Agency
PO Box 482 Lisbon, OH 44432
330-424-9533

Minor Insurance Agency - East Liverpool
15700 St. Rt. 170, Suite A East Liverpool, OH 43920
330-385-1370

Minor Insurance Agency - Minerva
956 E Lincoln Way Minerva, OH 44657
330-868-6913

Minor Insurance Agency - Toronto
1007 Franklin St., Suite B Toronto, OH 43964
740-537-1282

Mission Insurance Agency of Ohio LLC dba Mission Insurance Agency LLC
55 S High St Ste 208, Dublin OH 43017
614-368-9333

N C Nikolaides Ins Agency Inc
504 Elm Rd NE, Warren OH 44483
330-856-3699

Nelson Insurance Agency
405 N Main Street, Kenton, OH 43326
419-673-8256

Newland Heydinger Insurance Agency
111 E Columbus Street, Kenton, OH 43326
419-674-4116

R C Cook Insurance Agency Inc dba Cook Insurance Group
504 E Main St, Ravenna OH 44266
330-296-3628

Rall Insurance Services Company LLC dba Conner Insurance Agency
1569 E Main St, Lancaster OH 43130
740-654-2848

Rall Insurance Services Company LLC dba Quest Financial & Insurance Services
10574 Ravenna Rd 3rd Floor, Twinsburg OH 44087
855-857-9500

Roehrs-McMillen Insurance Inc
414 Clinton Street Defiance, OH 43512
419-784-3979

Rosemount City Insurance Agency
4746 Old Scioto Trail, PO Box 1308, Portsmouth OH 45662
740-354-6216

Royal Crest Agency
29 W Main St, Tipp City, OH 45371
937-667-9359

Safe Harbor Insurance Agency
2451 Sawmill Parkway, Huron, OH 44839
419-616-5207

Shinaberry Insurance Agency Inc
11 West High Street Mount Gilead, OH 43338-1212
419-947-9336

Sloan Insurance Center - Bellefontaine
1413 S Main ST Bellefontaine, OH 43311
937-592-4856

Sloan Insurance Center - North Lewisburg
PO Box 430 North Lewisburg, OH 43060-0430
937-747-2391

Stapleton Insurance Group / Herrick Insurance Agency
122 North Main Street PO Box 147 Swanton OH, 43558
419-720-6446

Stark Insurance Agency Inc
4125 Martindale NE Ste 300, Canton OH 44705
330-492-2300

Stockton-Hill Insurance
10212 St Rt 159, PO Box 648, Kingston OH 45644
740-642-3333

Straley Insurance Services
203 North Harrison Street Sherwood, OH 43556
419-899-4000

Summers Insurance Group
1436 S Cleveland-Massillon Rd, Copley OH 44321
330-665-3333

The Keenan Agency
6805 Avery-Muirfield Dr # 200, Dublin, OH 43016
614-764-7000

Thomas J Andrews
c/o Kemp Insurance Agency, 2146 E High Ave, New Philadelphia OH 44663
330-339-4211

Thompson Insurance - New Lexington
102 S Main St New Lexington, OH 43764
740-342-1986

Thompson Insurance - Thornville
14888 State Route 13 N Thornville, OH 43076
740-246-6100

Titan Insurance Services Ltd.
752 High Street, PO Box 141, Worthington OH 43085
614-398-1494

Ungashick Insurance Agency
4942 Higbee Ave NW Suite F, Canton OH 44718
330-492-1300

United Group Ins Agency Inc
2036 Locust St, PO Box 457, Canal Fulton OH 44614-0457
330-658-2111

United Independent Agency Alliance
2036 Locust St, PO Box 457, Canal Fulton OH 44614-0457
330-854-4504

United States Insurance Group
4526 Stow Rd, Stow OH 44224
330-688-0981

Wilde Corp
125 N Main St, Rittman OH 44270
330-927-6025